Top 5 Best Blenders for Milkshakes (2021 Review)

Looking for the best blender for milkshakes? 

Perfect, you’re in the right place! 

One of the most iconic American desserts, milkshakes are the perfect specialty drink loved by all ages.

For parents, whipping up a creamy strawberry milkshake for the kids is the ideal after-dinner treat while having control of all the ingredients. 

Finding the right blender to create the perfect (frothy yet just thick enough) milkshake becomes ever so important.

I’ve scavenged the market for the best blenders for milkshakes to make buying one easy for you! In this guide, you’ll learn:

  • What are the different kinds of milkshake blenders? 
  • What important features to look for in choosing your milkshake machine
  • And much more!

Below is a quick list of my favorite milkshake blenders. Keep scrolling to learn more of my top tips to choose and use the best blender for milkshakes.

ImageProduct
digital-business-prep-table__image
Ninja Professional Countertop Blender
  • Large Family Size Pitcher
  • Comes with 2 Single-Serve Cups
  • Powerful Blender Motor
  • Large Family Size Pitcher
  • Comes with 2 Single-Serve Cups
  • Powerful Blender Motor
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Vitamix 5200 Blender Professional-Grade
  • Most Powerful Motor
  • Variable Speed Control
  • Easy to Use
  • Most Powerful Motor
  • Variable Speed Control
  • Easy to Use
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Oster Blender | Pro 1200 with Glass Jar, 24-Ounce Smoothie Cup
  • Durable Glass Pitcher
  • 3 Pre-Programmed Speeds
  • 7 Year Warranty
  • Durable Glass Pitcher
  • 3 Pre-Programmed Speeds
  • 7 Year Warranty
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Hamilton Beach Pro Retro Die-Cast Mixer for Milkshakes
  • Specialty Milkshake Maker
  • Durable Design
  • Dishwasher Safe
  • Specialty Milkshake Maker
  • Durable Design
  • Dishwasher Safe
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
NutriBullet Pro 13 Pcs
  • Compact for Easy Storage
  • Easy to Use
  • Single-Serving Cups
  • Compact for Easy Storage
  • Easy to Use
  • Single-Serving Cups
View on Amazon

My Overall Top #1 Pick: Ninja Professional Countertop Blender

This Ninja model is basically the essential Ninja. It’s their large blender jar, with their unqiue blade design, in combination with the smaller single-serving cups that were added to the Ninja line a bit later than the original blender.

That combination makes this a great option if you’re looking to be able to make milkshakes for the family and wan to be able to make single-serve milkshakes as needed.

That’s great for people who have large families, who need to accommodate food allergies, or who want to make milkshakes for picky eaters.

This design is also particularly easy to use, with straightforward buttons and a simple blending system. Plus, since all of the blender jars and blades are fully contained, this model is far more spill-proof than most options.

Ninja also offers a particularly good setup for users who like thicker milkshakes (like me!) thanks to the efficient blade setup combined with a powerful motor.

Top 5 Best Blenders for Milkshakes

In a hurry? Check out my top 5 picks below! Keep reading to learn more about these blenders for milkshakes.

  1. Ninja Professional Countertop Blender ( Top Pick)
  2. Vitamix 5200 Blender Professional-Grade (Best High-End )
  3. Oster Pro 1200 Blender (Best Economic Pick )
  4. Hamilton Beach Pro Retro Die-Cast Mixer (Best for Milkshake Lovers)
  5. NutriBullet Pro 13 Pcs (Best for Single Servings)

What are the Advantages of a High-Quality blender for Milkshakes?

It’s important to have a high quality blender specifically for milkshakes because it needs to be powerful and durable enough to crush hard ice cream and frozen strawberries, yet be able to blend with smooth precision to create that creamy texture of the perfect milkshake. 

Want to make the whole thing from scratch? You can make your own ice cream in the blender too, and then turn it into a milkshake!

How to pick the best Milkshake Blender?

Picking a blender is similar to the experience of picking a car. With the large number of options — makes, models and features to choose from, it can be confusing.

It’s like the difference between choosing the Honda of blenders with a 400-watt motor and a plastic base versus the Lexus of blenders with a 1000-watt motor with a stainless steel base, 9 speed settings and a sleek design.

 The features to evaluate when choosing your Milkshake blender is power, speed settings, jar capacity, jar material, warranty, design, and budget.

How much Power do I need?

The more powerful your blender, the faster the blade will rotate around the central point and be able to crush ingredients like hard ice cream and frozen fruit. This is measured by the wattage number (typical blenders average about 500W), which measures the power of the blender motor.

It’s important to find a suitable blender that is powerful enough to crush all the ingredients to make a silky smooth drink– you don’t want chunks of fruit or lumpy ice cream to be detected in your milkshake!

Also, if you’re planning on making your milkshake concoction for a larger group of people, you will want a more powerful machine. 

Or, if you want to do something a little more complicated, check out my list of the best blenders for Shakeology.

Check out some tips on how to make a milkshake the right way:

How many Speed Settings do I need?

Blenders also differ in their speed settings.

Some are more simplistic with three-speed settings (low, medium, high) while others have seven or more speed settings which can be more versatile if you plan on using your blender to do more than making milkshakes such as chop vegetables and puree soup.

Some more advanced blenders even have pre-programmed settings for specific use cases (such as for milkshakes, smoothies, or hot soups) that have a countdown timer allowing for easy, hands-free blending.

The blenders we’ve provided in this review we’ve found to be especially best for milkshakes with specific settings to create that super smooth creamy milkshake texture. Pulse settings are great for preventing overprocessing.

What Jar Size am I looking for?

Depending on if you’re looking for a personal blender or one to make milkshakes for a large family, different blender models have varying jar sizes. If you’re looking for a compact personal blender this can be as small as 26 ounces whereas a larger more heavy duty blender can be as big as 68 ounces.

Want to add some coffee flavor to your milkshakes? The best way is to use fresh ground coffee beans, or coffee made with them. Here’s how you can grind coffee beans even if you don’t have a specialized coffee grinder.

What Blender Material do I want?

Blender jars come in three materials — plastic, glass, and stainless steel. The difference in material does not affect blender performance but each comes with its own set of pros and cons:

  • Plastic is the most commonly used material for blenders with benefits of being lighter weight and more durable (won’t shatter if dropped on the floor). However, the quality of plastic can vary greatly from blender to blender. Cheaper blenders typically use lower-grade plastic which are not dishwasher-safe, are prone to scratches and can end up smelling like their contents. More expensive blenders however, use higher-grade plastic or copolyester, which has benefits such as better durability, heat and scratch resistance, and is BPA-free.  Read here for why choosing a BPA-free blender for milkshakes is important, keeping you and your family safe from the toxic effects of BPA poisoning.
  • Glass jars have several benefits –they’re scratch-resistant, does not discolor, and less likely to retain odors. They are dishwasher-safe and are versatile for both cold and hot contents. Some consumers also love glass jars because they look nicer, and feel more durable. But the downside is that they tend to be heavier and this aspect should be considered especially for those with arthritic hands or for the elderly. Glass material is also more at risk for being shattered if dropped. 
  • Stainless steel blenders are most commonly seen in restaurant settings with their professional look, and have recently transitioned into the home but usually comes with a hefty price tag. Consumers who opt in for this material love the sleek and modern look, and can match any decor from wood to marble. The downside to this material is that the jar won’t be transparent, making it difficult to blend your milkshakes to the proper consistency without stopping the blender every few minutes to peek inside. 

What sort of Warranty should my blender have?

It’s important to look for a blender with a good warranty. Many blenders come with a 1-year warranty, but some come with a longer timeframe, 5 year, 10 year or even lifetime warranty. 

What Design am I going for?

Some milkshake blenders have a cool, retro-look while others look like regular blenders.

Consider your kitchen set up and the look you’re going for when choosing the right milkshake blender for you.

Also, think through where you want your blender in the kitchen — if it’s going to live on the countertop and tucked under your cabinets, be sure to measure the blender dimensions to ensure it will fit!  

What’s my Budget?

The ideal for many home cooks seems to be within that $50-$100 price range that performs like a high end, commercial blender that costs upwards of $500.

However, in the blender world, it’s true that you get what you pay for. Higher end blenders ($150+) come with higher power, can produce smoother textures and generally last longer than cheaper blenders. But if a cheaper blender is what you can afford, just be cognizant of its limitations. 

I highly recommend buying the best blender you can afford. It’s an appliance worth investing in!

My Reviews of the Best Blenders for Milkshakes

1. Ninja Professional Countertop Blender (My Top Pick)

Product Features:

  • Comes with 3 Plastic Jars
  • 1 72 oz Pitcher Jar
  • 2 16 oz Single-Serve Cups
  • 2 Stainless Steel Blades
  • 1 Blender Base
  • 1100 Watt Base

I love that this blender is one of the more powerful options for a family sized-blender. That makes it a lot easier to make milkshakes for the whole family, or just use the single serve jars to make a treat for yourself.

This design is also particularly effective for getting an evenly-mixed milkshake, especially if you want to add difficult to blend ingredients like malt balls. It’s also great for building up the frothy thick texture of a great milkshake.

Unfortunately, this model still has the biggest problem with the previous models. It’s very loud. That’s true of most Ninja models, though I agree with most users that the power of these blenders is worth dealing with a little extra noise.

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Unique tiered blade helps improve milkshake consistency
+ Great for thicker milkshakes and difficult to blend ingredients
+ Large pitcher is perfect for making a lot of milkshake at once
+ Smaller sized cups are perfect for making single-serve milkshakes
– This blender is very loud
– Need to be a little careful with the plastic pitchers, they can crack or chip if dropped.

2. Vitamix 5200 Blender (Best High End)

Product Features:

  • 64 oz Pitcher
  • Aircraft-grade stainless steel blades
  • Comfortable plastic grip handle
  • Easy pour spout and lid
  • 7-year manufacturer warranty
  • 20 variable speed control
  • 120 V Motor

Largely considered the gold standard for blenders, Vitamix is known for producing powerful and versatile blenders.

We found the 5200 to not only be effective for producing that thick and silky milkshake texture but also versatile for all your other blending needs (literally everything — from grinding coffee beans to transforming peanuts into creamy peanut butter!)

The downside is that this blender comes with a heftier price tag than my other milkshake blender picks.

That being said, if you’re ready to shell out the cash for the quality of a high-end commercial-grade blender, this is one of the highest-reviewed Vitamix blenders on Amazon (With nearly 2,000 reviews with 1,700 perfect 5-star ratings).

The 5200 has a tall, 64-ounce container perfect for making milkshakes for the entire family.

While it doesn’t have any pre-programmed button settings, it offers a variable speed dial allowing you to select the exact speed you want your blender to run in creating the perfect textured milkshake.

And unlike other blenders with either sharp or dull blades, the Vitamix 5200 blade (made of aircraft-grade stainless steel) is precision engineered to perform both actions. I found this blade to be impressive in cutting through rock hard ice cream. 

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Powerful motor is great for adding candies, cookies, and other mix-ins to your milkshake
+ Large jar capacity perfect for making milkshakes with a family
+ Speed variability gives you a lot more control over your milkshake texture
+ 7 year warranty for added peace of mind that you’ll be covered if something goes wrong
– Speed dial can be a little sticky, especially when you first get the unit
– May not start blending thick ingredients right away unless you use the tamper

3. Oster Pro 1200 Blender (Best Economic Option)

Product Features:

  • 10 year warranty on metal parts
  • Borosilicate glass pitcher, protects from thermal shock
  • 1200 Watt base, 900 watt crushing power
  • 3 programmed speeds
  • 24 ox smoothie cup included

Sleek with brushed nickel and with a classy glass jar, this blender is my top budget pick.

At 48 ounces, the jar capacity is large enough for milkshakes for the family.

The stainless steel blade system is 50% larger than previous models, with the patented feature of forward and reverse motion for better performance and even blending for your creamy milkshake.

I love how this blender has pre-programmed settings for the most common blending creations, including the milkshake to create that perfect drink yet also has 3-speed settings.

It also has pulse control for added control and precision for chopping food and crushing ice. Blender also comes with an additional 24 oz smoothie cup.

Those features are part of what make this blender a really great option if you’re on a budget. It’s a little more affordable than most blenders with a good motor and an effective blade system, but this blender really packs a lot of value into a small package.

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ This is a great option for a budget-friendly-blender
+ Dishwasher safe with glass jar
+ Borosilicate glass means you don’t have to worry about thermal shock, use ice, syrups, and whatever other ingredients you like
+ 10-year warranty on the most critical parts of this blender
– Customer service from this manufacturer isn’t great
– Buying additional pitchers or other accessories for this blender can be difficult

4. Hamilton Beach Pro Retro Die-Cast Mixer: (Best for Milkshake Lovers)

Product Features:

  • Specifically designed for milkshakes
  • 100 watt motor
  • 15.63 inches tall
  • 5.88 lbs
  • Stainless steel mixer
  • Dishwasher safe design

We love this product for its vintage, classic look and is specifically designed for making milkshakes. Its sleek look is as a result of the durable die-cast aluminum housing paired with its stainless steel mixing cup.

The product features a commercial-grade mixing spindle, 2 speeds with precision motor, all allowing for hands-free mixing.

The product takes us back to diner days as it can make restaurant-quality malts, shakes, and soda fountain drinks. It’s also great for making protein shakes or stirring up omelets, pancake batter and more. The Hamilton Beach pro comes with a stainless steel, dishwasher-safe mixing cup that you can easily clean by hand or pop up into the dishwasher. It comes with a 5 year warranty, which passes my test for ease of mind and guaranteed durability!

If you’re a true milkshake lover, having a dedicated appliance for them not only makes things easier, it also can improve the flavor and texture of your milkshakes. Plus, this milkshake mixer is even easier to use than many blender.

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Sleek, Retro design helps bring back nostalgia for getting a milkshake at a diner
+ 5 year warranty for added peace of mine
+ Dishwasher safe desgin
+ Fast blending makes milkshakes much quicker than a regular blender
– Not a good option for more versatile blending

5. NutriBullet Pro 13 Pcs (Best for Single Servings)

Product Features:

  • 2 Single Serving Ups included
  • 2 Locking Lids
  • 2 Cup Rings
  • 2 Cup Ring + Handle
  • 900 Watts Motor Power
  • Stainless Steel Extractor Blades

This blender is a little different from the other options we’ve discussed. But, it’s still designed for milkshakes, smoothies, and other thicker beverages.

The single-serving design, and widely available accessories and additional parts for this blender make it a wonderful option for making individual milkshakes. Great whether it’s just you, or if your family all have different favorite flavors when it comes to milkshakes.

This option is also great for anyone who needs to be able to make a quick drink on the go thanks to the incredibly fast blending speed with this blender. It will make a milkshake, protein shake, coffee frappe, or smoothie in just a couple of minutes.

Nutribullet has had a few different models of their iconic blender on the market. Each one has made small improvements to the model, from better blending power to better fitting cup lids. This version isn’t truly the most recent, but it’s one of the better models they’ve offered. Plus, the set this one comes with helps save a little on the additional accessories for your blender.

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Powerful motor provides incredibly fast blending
+Great for thicker beverages like milkshakes and smoothies
+ Easy to use
+Dishwasher safe for easier cleanup
– Can leak if the cup isn’t closed tightly

My Top Pick: Ninja Professional Countertop Blender

Overall, even though this model isn’t the most advanced blender on my list, that would have to be either the Vitamix or the specialty Milkshake maker, I stand by this being the most balanced option. It’s great for making large batches of milkshakes quickly and efficiently, and also gives you the option to make smaller amounts whenever you like.

The powerful motor, easy pour spout, and innovative blade design all make it easier and more fun to enjoy your favorite milkshake flavors.

Final Thoughts On The Best Blender for Milkshakes

Choosing the right blender to meet your kitchen needs is an important decision.

There are a lot of factors that could influence what type of blender to buy, including the power you need, jar capacity for your family size, design you want to match your kitchen decor, and warranty guarantee.

Above all else, make sure you choose the highest quality blender you can afford. 

There is no wrong answer here, but it’s no secret that not all blenders are created equal. Just as not all milkshakes are created equal, not all blenders are created equal…and I want you to maximize your chances for creating that perfect milkshake!

Heather

Heather

My love for food brings me here. Over the last couple years, I've been building out my repertoire of the best kitchen gadgets and appliances to whip up my favorite meals. I'm on a mission to help you do the same, so you can bring out the spice of life in your kitchen and define your unique Kitchen Culture!

Leave a Comment

Heather

Heather

My love for food brings me here. Over the last couple years, I've been building out my repertoire of the best kitchen gadgets and appliances to whip up my favorite meals. I'm on a mission to help you do the same, so you can bring out the spice of life in your kitchen and define your unique Kitchen Culture!

About My Kitchen Culture

Here at My Kitchen Culture, I review the best kitchen gadgets and appliances so that you can get everything you need to create your favorite foods in your kitchen. 

Recently Published Guides