Top 5 Best Blenders for Nut Butter (2020 Review)

Nut butter is a delicious addition to your breakfast, lunch, or even dinner.

They’re great for making snacks to share, and homemade versions are often even tastier than store bought varieties.

Plus, when you’re making your own nut butters, it’s easy to find your own combinations of nuts, and to create the exact textures you prefer. 

Nut butters are also an incredibly healthy addition to your diet, and are a diet friendly source of fats, proteins, and sugars that can help you feel fuller and more satisfied after your meal. 

It might seem challenging to make your own nut butter at home at first, but the process is simple enough as long as you have a good blender. 

That’s why I’ve put this guide together. Not every blender can handle making nut butters, but once you have a blender that can, you’ll never go back to store-bought again. 

In this guide, you’ll learn

  • What features your blender need to make nut butter
  • Details that make it easier to make nut butter
  • And much more!

Below is a quick list of my favorite blenders for nut butter. Keep scrolling to learn more of my top tips to choose and use the Best Blender for Nut Butter.

ImageProduct
digital-business-prep-table__image
Hamilton Beach Professional Quiet Shield Blender
  • Noise shield to reduce the sound of making nut butter
  • 1,500 watt blender
  • Tamper included with the blender
  • Noise shield to reduce the sound of making nut butter
  • 1,500 watt blender
  • Tamper included with the blender
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Vitamix, Black 7500 Blender
  • 64oz durable glass jar
  • Long 6ft power cord
  • 10 speeds for added power and control
  • 64oz durable glass jar
  • Long 6ft power cord
  • 10 speeds for added power and control
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Instant Ace Nova Blender
  • Lots of speed settings for different food types
  • Also a cooking tool
  • Designed with nut butters and milks in mind
  • Lots of speed settings for different food types
  • Also a cooking tool
  • Designed with nut butters and milks in mind
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Ninja Mega Kitchen System
  • Comprehensive kitchen system with multiple jars and blending/food processing options
  • Large 72 oz pitcher
  • All components (except the power base) are dishwasher safe
  • Comprehensive kitchen system with multiple jars and blending/food processing options
  • Large 72 oz pitcher
  • All components (except the power base) are dishwasher safe
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
NutriBullet ZNBF30400Z Blender 1200 Watts
  • 1,200 watt motor
  • Tamper included
  • Jar designed to encourage even mixing/blending
  • 1,200 watt motor
  • Tamper included
  • Jar designed to encourage even mixing/blending
View on Amazon

My Overall Top #1 Pick: Hamilton Beach Professional Quiet Shield Blender

Part of Hamilton Beach’s Professional line, this blender is a clear winner when it comes to nut butters thanks to the durable sound shield that cuts down on the loud sound while blending your own nut butter. 

You’ll be a lot more likely to continue making your own nut butters, and experimenting with different recipes and ingredients, when the process is a lot more pleasant. 

This blender is moderately priced, but more powerful that you’d expect from such an affordable appliance. The 1,500 watt motor is more than powerful enough to tackle grinding and blending nuts, and just about anything else. 

I also really appreciated that this is a blender that offers both 4 blending modes, which are designed for specific foods, and a 1-10 power setting mode. Normally blenders come with one or the other, but having both gives you a lot more flexibility. 

The 32 oz jar is a little smaller than some of the other blenders on this list, but still plenty big enough to handle making large batches of nut butter. The included tamper also makes the whole process a lot easier, without having to start and stop the blender to make sure you’re getting an even blend.

Top 5 Best Blenders for Nut Butter

In a hurry? Check out our top 5 picks below! Keep reading to learn more about the best blenders for nut butter.

  1. Hamilton Beach Professional Quiet Shield Blender (My Top Pick)
  2. Vitamix, Black 7500 Blender (Best High-End)
  3. Instant Ace Nova Blender (Best Budget)
  4. Ninja Mega Kitchen System
  5. NutriBullet ZNBF30400Z Blender 1200 Watts

What are the Advantages of a High Quality Blender for Nut Butter? 

High quality blenders give you several advantages over cheaper blenders when making nut butters (and pretty much everything else). 

Most importantly, high quality blenders have significantly more powerful motors. Power equals versatility when it comes to blenders. Especially when you want to start making nut butters and home, you need a reasonable amount of power to make sure your blender can grind through the nuts without overheating or stressing the motor. 

High-quality blenders also tend to be much quieter than their cheaper counterparts. They rattle less than other blenders, and the jars are usually better insulated for quieter operation. 

Think about shaking a container of mixed nuts. Now imagine the sound of a motor, and shaking the nuts much faster. That’s the sound level you’re talking about when you’re making a good nut butter, so sound reduction is a very good trait to have. 

The last thing I want to mention is that high quality blenders are much less likely to wear out due to the stress of grinding nuts, which means that buying a better blender is less expensive over time.

Read More >> Top 5 Blenders for Hummus

Blenders that aren’t as well designed, or that use lower quality components, are much more likely to burn out if you use them regularly, and especially if you like to make foods that can challenge the blender. Anything with nuts or ice, or even frozen fruits, can be challenging for a poorly-designed blender. 

If you’re not sure about making nut butters yourself, this video is a great tutorial showing how easy a simple nut butter recipe can be when you have a great blender.

How to Pick the Best Blender for Nut Butter?

Picking the best blender for nut butter can be quite tricky because there are a lot to choose from. There are several things to consider when picking a blender such as: power, speed, jar size, material, warranty, and design.

Power: 

Nuts are relatively hard, even though they break down into delicious butters and milks with the right preparation. That hardness means that you need a fairly powerful motor to process them effectively. Less powerful motors might get the job done, but they are also more likely to break in the process and won’t last as long. 

Generally, look for blenders that offer at least 1,000 watts of power, and more is better. Power doesn’t have to translate to speed, which I’ll talk about in a moment. What it does is provide more consistency in the blade, and enough power to move through even thick patches of nuts as they begin to grind into butter. 

Read More >> 5 Ways You’re Cleaning Your Blender Wrong

Speed: 

Variable speeds can be very useful when you’re making nut butter, from faster speeds that are suited to breaking nuts down into a manageable size and shape, down to the middling speeds that work to turn coarse butters into smooth and creamy spreads. 

Look for blenders that have 4 or more speed settings, with closer to 10 being the ideal. Variable speed options are also good for helping to process more than one type of nut, and for developing your own process. 

Be careful with higher speeds though. Blenders tend to start to heat up a little if you leave them on the highest speed settings for too long. The heat itself is hard on the blender, so you may want to give it a break if you notice the base getting warm. 

Like many other ingredients, nut butters can also change flavor slightly if they are warmed, especially milder and sweeter butters made from delicate nuts like cashews. 

Jar Size: 

Nut butters are long-lasting, so I like to make large batches so that I don’t have to make them very often. With that in mind, I tend to recommend jars starting at about 32oz, though I don’t recommend completely filling jars that large when you first start. 

The larger your jar, the larger batches you can make. But you should only add your nuts slowly, a small portion at a time, to make sure you don’t overwhelm the motor. 

Material: 

Glass jars are usually much more durable than their plastic counterparts. That said, a good plastic jar can be a good option because they are more lightweight, and less thermal sensitive than some kinds of glass. 

Most of my blender recommendations use glass jars made of pyrex. That’s because glass is very durable, resists taking on stains and scents from the food you’re making, and is resistant to thermal shock so that it can handle both hot and cold foods. 

Not all glass is created equal though, so you should always check whether your blender is hot and cold safe. 

There is one set on here, the Ninja Kitchen System, that uses plastic jars. The plastic is less durable, but it’s still a reasonable option for people who need a more lightweight system, or who are looking to get the most out of the motor or blades and don’t mind saving a little money on the jar system.

If you’re considering plastic blender jars, you should always look to make sure the plastic is thermal resistant, just like glass, and BPA-free. BPA are harmful chemicals that can be added to plastics to make them stronger, but which leech into your food and beverages over time.

BPA free plastic is perfectly safe to use, but plastics with BPA can be harmful and alter the taste of whatever they’re exposed to.

Fortunately, most consumer kitchen plastics are now BPA-free, but it’s still important to check for the label, just in case. The Ninja Kitchen System is BPA free, as are all Ninja blender jars, thankfully.

Warranty: 

I like to look for a minimum of a year warranty on blenders. That timeframe is typically enough to cover problems that happen from lemon items (items that have a problem that can’t be found by quality check) and other incidentals. 

A year of regular use also tends to give me a good sense of what a blender can do, so the warranty can at least partially cover problems if a blender isn’t quite up to what I thought it could do. 

If you can, look for longer warranties on the base and motor systems. Jars and other accessories can usually be replaced at reasonable costs. But if it’s the motor or the base that fails, you need a new blender. 

Unfortunately, warranties that last longer than a year are relatively rare, but they are out there. 

Design: 

Blenders that are rounded, wider at the top, and narrower at the bottom, tend to work better than blenders that are squared off, or that have jars of universal width. A perfectly round blender jar also likely won’t work better than a jar with small smooth inserts to help improve movement in the blender. 

Blenders also tend to be relatively tall, with a wide base. The base’s width is a lot more than just aesthetics (though I don’t blame you if you’re also looking for a blender that fits in with the rest of your kitchen appliances). 

Wider blender bases add stability, and reduce the chance that the blender will start to rock on it’s base. The jar’s base should be narrow, and should be placed in the middle of a much wider base. 

Read More >> How to Make Ice Cream with a Ninja Blender (5 Step Guide)

My Reviews of the Best Blenders for Nut Butter

1. Hamilton Beach Professional Quiet Shield Blender

This blender has an innovative sound shield, normally only found on restaurant and bar blenders. This feature cuts the noise so that making nut butters is a lot more pleasant. 

The blender is designed with 4 pre-designed speed modes for things like smoothies and purees. You also get a second speed control option that’s 10 speed settings from low-high that gives you more direct control over blending power, perfect for the different phases of making nut butter.

This combination helps you handle a wide range of different tasks and ingredients, with custom control when you need it, and proven speed settings when you don’t.

It also offers a flat speed range of 10 different settings, so that you have immediate control over the speed of your blender for other kinds of food. 

The motor offers 1,500 watts of power. The jar is both shatterproof and thermal resistant, so it’s unlikely to break, and even if something does go wrong, the jar will crack instead of shattering. 

I also appreciate that the blades are made from the same kind of high-quality stainless steel used in other appliances and kitchen knives. 

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Noise shield for quieter operation
+ Dishwasher safe shatterproof glass jar
+ Lots of power and flexibility
+ Cleaning mode to make washing up easier
+ 5 year limited warranty
– No handle on the blender jar itself
– Replacement jars are expensive compared to the total price of the blender

2. Vitamix, Black 7500 Blender 

Vitamix is one of the most trusted names in high-end blenders, and this version is no exception. While it doesn’t offer a noise shield, the system is relatively quiet, and every component is made from highly durable materials. 

The jaw is designed specifically to help encourage ingredient turnover, which helps make sure that your creamy nut butters are creamy, not crunchy. 

The 64 oz container is well suited to making large batches of nut butters, in addition to handling just about anything else. It’s large enough to blend soups in fewer batches, but unlike some large-jar blenders, doesn’t struggle with smaller amounts.

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Blades made from incredibly durable stainless steel 
+ Large 64oz jar
+ Self-cleaning wash mode
+ Low profile to fit under kitchen cabinets
– Low profile design needs a little more help mixing than taller versions

3. Instant Ace Nova Blender

This blender is something a little different, it’s an affordable blender that is also designed to help cook your food. 

It’s powerful enough to easily make nut butters, and it’s a more versatile design since it’s also a soup cooker. 

This option is great if you’re looking to get a versatile and multi-purpose blender for a smaller space. It’s also a good option if you’re looking for a blender for more difficult tasks that won’t break the bank.

The blender is equipped with a wide range of different blending settings that are pre-programmed. Using those settings, you can be blending while also taking care of something else in your kitchen at the same time. 

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Lets you multitask while blending
+ Also has warming and cooking settings for cooking and blending at the same time
+ Durable and affordable
– Tends to overheat small portions
– Has a plastic component near the motor that melts if the blender overheats
– Relatively loud

4. Ninja Mega Kitchen System

If you’re looking for a complete kitchen blending system, this version is a good option. The jars are all plastic, but in this bundle you get a versatile blender and a food processor in one. 

This system is particularly good for nut butters because it gives you different tools for approaching different parts of the process, or different kinds of nuts. 

But it’s also a good system if you have the storage space and are just looking for a very complete, and very powerful, blender set. The motor is durable and reliable, and while the jar is plastic, they tend to be more durable than most plastic blender jars.

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Blender and food processor
+ Unique blade design creates a more even texture
+ Comes with different jars for different size jobs
– Plastic jars, and the jars get cloudy over time
– Square design lets nut butters and other thicker purees stick in the corners

5. NutriBullet ZNBF30400Z Blender 1200 Watts

Nutribullet has been making more of a name for themselves with a wider expanded line of blenders that can tackle more than the original nutribullet system was designed to handle. 

This blender is a good all-purpose mid-range blender that supplies enough power to make nut butters and other high-power demand foods. 

Its slightly different jar design, which comes to a narrow bottom, but widens out much faster than average, does a good job of encouraging ingredient mixing in the jar. 

It does have a much more limited set of speeds than the other blenders I’ve reviewed. But, the included recipe book does a good job of overcoming that limitation by giving you several examples of how to best utilize the provided speeds. 

PROS (+)CONS (-)
+ Wider jar for large batches
+ Lots of power for the price
+ Works well as an all-purpose blender
+ Dishwasher friendly
– Only runs for 1 minute intervals
– Pour spout design is slightly tricky

My Top Pick: Hamilton Beach Professional Quiet Shield Blender

While I stand by all of these blenders, the Hamilton Beach Professional Quiet Shield Blender has a lot of advantages when it comes to making nut butters specifically. It’s a powerful, well-priced, and relatively quiet blender. 

Plus, since it’s designed with professional use in mind, it’s also more durable than a lot of consumer blenders. That’s huge since making nut butters is a relatively difficult task for your blender, and since you’ll probably want to use your blender for a lot more than just nut butters. 

This option also stands out as a good option for smaller apartments and homes, since it cuts down on the noise.

Final Thoughts On The Best Blender for Nut Butter

There are so many more options than just peanut butter or almond butter once you’re making your own nut butters at home. Having a great blender like the ones I’ve reviewed today will open up a ton of new tastes and textures since you can make your butters at home and experiment with the flavors as much as you like. 

Don’t worry if you’re a little overwhelmed with some of the options, I found this great video to give you some flavored nut butter ideas that are still really healthy and easy to make. Plus, the video host also talks about how different nuts create different textures in the butter, which is great as a nut butter primer.

Now that you know which blenders are the best for making nut butter, there’s just one last thing. Happy blending!

Heather

Heather

My love for food brings me here. Over the last couple years, I've been building out my repertoire of the best kitchen gadgets and appliances to whip up my favorite meals. I'm on a mission to help you do the same, so you can bring out the spice of life in your kitchen and define your unique Kitchen Culture!

1 thought on “Top 5 Best Blenders for Nut Butter (2020 Review)”

Leave a Comment

Heather

Heather

My love for food brings me here. Over the last couple years, I've been building out my repertoire of the best kitchen gadgets and appliances to whip up my favorite meals. I'm on a mission to help you do the same, so you can bring out the spice of life in your kitchen and define your unique Kitchen Culture!

About My Kitchen Culture

Here at My Kitchen Culture, I review the best kitchen gadgets and appliances so that you can get everything you need to create your favorite foods in your kitchen. 

Recently Published Guides